top of page

2025 NCAA D1 XC Championships First Thoughts: Lemngole Defeats Hedengren, Samuel's Big Surge, Oklahoma State Men Dominate & NC State Women Win NCAA Title

Writer: Admin (Garrett Zatlin)
Admin (Garrett Zatlin)
Nov 22, 2025
10 min read

Updated: Nov 22, 2025

And with that, ladies and gentlemen, the 2025 NCAA cross country season has concluded. With it comes the end of multiple storylines and the exciting build up that took place going into Saturday.


Our content crew was hard at work in Columbia, Missouri, gathering photos and video from the season finale. If you haven't already, be sure to check out our YouTube page for all of the content there!


Below are a few initial thoughts and analysis on the major headlines from Saturday. This article won't be quite as long as most of our "First Thoughts" articles usually are. Part of that is because we are pressed for time, while the other part is because I want to save some analysis for our final set of analysis and rankings.


Alright, let's dive in...

Alabama's Doris Lemngole Goes Back-to-Back, Defeats BYU Rookie Phenom Jane Hedengren for NCAA Title

Going into Saturday, it seemed more than fair to say that the women's battle for the individual national title would come down to Alabama's Doris Lemngole and BYU's Jane Hedengren.


The former had quite easily been the most dominant collegiate distance runner in the NCAA over the last 15 months. The latter, however, was an all-time high school phenom who was showcasing a level of dominance this season that was unheard of for a true freshman.


But on Saturday, it was, in fact, Doris Lemngole who took control of the race and ultimately ended up pulling away for the second individual cross country national title of her career. While Hedengren did make an early effort to establish the pace, it was Lemngole who put herself in the lead and kept it that way to the finish line.


Doris Lemngole crosses the finish line to win the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay
Doris Lemngole crosses the finish line to win the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay

Put simply, Lemngole was flat-out better. Her experience and her fitness were simply greater than the first-year talent out of Provo. There's a reason why we're beginning to ask, and maybe even suggest, that Lemngole is the greatest collegiate distance runner of all-time.


Hedengren does, however, deserve a ton of credit. There were numerous instances where Lemngole could have made a surge, ultimately dropping the BYU rookie. It wasn't until there was a little less than a half-mile to go before the Alabama phenom finally shook off a freshman who, at multiple times, looked ready to strike.


Despite how tight most of us at The Stride Report thought the women's individual battle would be, the rest of the country seemed to think otherwise. In fact, it felt like the general consensus was that Hedengren was the clear favorite to win NCAA gold!


If you think I'm just making this up, then I suggest looking at this post from another media outlet, the comments under our latest podcast episode on Youtube (yes, we read them...sometimes) and the replies under our video highlighting the Lemngole vs Hedengren matchup.


Heck, one guy even said on our Instagram page that he, "bet [his] hair on Jane."


But us at The Stride Report? Five of our six D1 writers chose Lemngole.



I made it clear in our latest episode of The Stride Report Podcast that Hedengren deserved to be considered as a national title favorite alongside Lemngole. I said that it wouldn't have shocked me if she won. I'm also not blaming anyone for taking Hedengren in their predictions -- I completely understood their decisions.


However, for some distance running fans to suggest (multiple times) that Hedengren was going to win by 30+ seconds over Lemngole felt...insulting. Like, REALLY insulting. It felt like the hype of what Hedengren could be (and probably will be) overshadowed what Doris Lemngole currently is.


No, I wasn't rooting against Hedengren or anything along those lines. Outside of Virginia Tech, I don't have a personal rooting interest -- I was just surprised that the narrative seemed to be so one-sided.


At the end of the day, I have never in my lifetime seen a true freshman woman look as poised, as fit and/or as dangerous as Hedengren did at the NCAA XC Championships this past Saturday (especially when you consider who she was going up against). At the 4000-meter split, I legitimately thought she was going to overtake Lemngole for gold -- she looked that good.



She didn't win, but Hedengren did set the table for what could be a career that may even eclipse that of Lemngole. Sure, a lot needs to happen between now and then, but it's still very much in play.


And Doris? Well, there are now even fewer arguments against the idea that she is the single-greatest NCAA distance runner of all-time.


New Mexico's Habtom Samuel Wins First NCAA XC Title, Utilizes Surprisingly Conservative Race Approach

Habtom Samuel is a special talent.


He was special before he came to the NCAA, he was special during his first year in the NCAA and he has only become more special since then. Aerobically, he has been one of the most dominant collegiate distance runners in recent memory.


And yet, despite those credentials, the New Mexico megastar only held one national title on his resume going into Saturday: a 10k victory at the 2024 NCAA Outdoor Championships. In total, across all three seasons (including this one), Samuel has amassed 11 All-American honors, five of which have been runner-up results.


Habtom Samuel celebrates near the finish line at the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay
Habtom Samuel celebrates near the finish line at the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay

Naturally, many wondered if his national title drought would finally come to an end at this year's NCAA XC Championships. He was, after all, the clear-cut favorite to win gold...but history suggested otherwise.


And through 8000 meters of racing, it seemed like there was a chance for Samuel to be defeated once again. With 2000 meters to go, a massive number of top-tier stars were still at/near the lead pack!


That was incredibly surprising. Not just because the lead pack is usually much smaller at that point in the race, but because Samuel has been known as an aggressive pace pusher -- a late-race kick, in theory, didn't favor him.


That, however, is exactly what caught the rest of the field by surprise, something that Wake Forest's Rocky Hansen even mentioned in a post-race interview. Samuel's lethal surge with less than 2000 meters to go clearly caught his competition off guard. And by the time everyone tried to react, Samuel had already established too much of a gap to be caught (despite an admirable effort from Hansen).



With this win, Samuel's resume finally feels...complete. Or at least, complete enough to talk about him with the lore that we want to.


His times on the track have been other-worldly and his aggressive front-running approach has led to plenty of fireworks. But having just one national title? Well, that didn't suggest to a still-learning fan that he was one of the naturally gifted distance runners of this era.


As for Hansen, his runner-up result feels like a major step in the right direction for his own goals of eventually winning a national title. He was the only one to have any shot of catching Samuel...even if his chances were extremely slim.


The issue, however, is that Samuel is "only" a junior -- the same as Hansen. If the Wake Forest product is going to don NCAA gold around his neck before he concludes his time as a collegian, then he'll likely need to win it on the track in races that favor his turnover.


NC State Women Win NCAA XC Championships Over BYU & Oregon, Produce Four Individual All-Americans

Going into the NCAA XC Championships, the women's team title battle was expected to come down to three programs: NC State, BYU and Oregon. Sure enough, that's exactly what happened with the former taking the national title.


And yet, while that trio of powerhouse programs were each expected to have realistic shots at NCAA gold, it was clear that NC State held the most balance. They had both the firepower and the depth to win it all.


Sure enough, Hannah Gapes (5th) and Grace Hartman (6th) were beyond outstanding, but unsurprisingly so. Both women have proven to be true elite stars in the past, although this was undoubtedly Gapes' best performance of the season (and likely her career).



Admittedly, the gap after those two women was larger than I was expecting. I figured that NC State would have a third woman cracking the top-20, but that didn't happen. Steeplechase superstar Angelina Napoleon faded to 40th place overall, the final individual All-American spot, despite being viewed as a top-10 threat.


Thankfully, sophomore Bethany Michalak capped a brilliant fall campaign with a 29th place All-American honor. It was a result that perfectly mimicked where we viewed her in the hierarchy of NCAA stars coming into this weekend. After Napoleon in 40th place was freshman Sadie Engelhardt who closed out the Wolfpack's team scoring with a serviceable 51st place effort.


In the end, NC State scored 114 points, defeating a runner-up BYU team that was 16 points back with 130 points.


Despite winning the national title, I don't think this was NC State's best performance of the season. Sure, Gapes and Hartman were fantastic, but Napoleon was obviously capable of offering more. You could also argue that Engelhardt was an All-American candidate on her best day.



Of course, it's important to remember that this team is coached by Laurie Henes. The Wolfpack women don't always have to be firing on all cylinders in order to be a national title threat. After all, just two years ago, NC State won the national team title despite Katelyn Tuohy being ill, Kelsey Chmiel being injured, Sam Bush having a not-so-great fall campaign and Amaris Tyynismaa having not finished a race that season until the national meet.


The lore of Coach Laurie Henes continues to grow. She has now won four national titles in five years, requiring just a one-year rebuild in 2024 to return to the top of the podium. She is rapidly approaching the "Greatest of All-Time" conversation among the NCAA cross country coaching ranks, at least for women's programs. And truthfully, there's a very good chance that she adds a few more national titles to her resume before all is said and done.


But maybe the most impressive part? Henes has done all of this organically, building a team with women who she recruited as high schoolers. Fleur Templier, the team's seventh runner on Saturday, was the only transfer in NC State's lineup.


Oh, and let's not forget -- NC State returns all five of their scorers for next fall.



When it comes to BYU, you have to give them credit -- they were within very reasonable striking distance of the national title.


Sure, Jane Hedengren (2nd) was phenomenal, but seeing teammate Riley Chamberlain take 4TH PLACE was absolutely stunning. Sure, we knew she was good, but a top-five finish at the NCAA XC Championships? Well, that completely blew us away.


Ultimately, NC State's supporting cast was simply stronger by comparison -- the Cougars' middle-lineup scorers, while solid, weren't as potent as what Michalak offered with her top-30 All-American performance.


Even so, Nelah Roberts (41st), Taylor Rohatinsky (47th) and Taylor Lovell (55th) deserve a lot of credit. Those three women packed together, eliminated gaps, didn't let the team score get out of control and got within reasonable striking distance of NC State's support scorers.


All things considered, I thought they ran fairly well.



As for Oregon, they had four individual All-American women, the same as NC State and two more than BYU. The issue, however, is that the potency of the Ducks' top women wasn't quite as strong as we thought it would.


Sure, Silan Ayyildiz (9th) was fantastic, but Diana Cherotich (31st) and Juliet Cherubet (39th) were each capable of being at least 20 spots better. That limited upper-tier scoring potency is ultimately what forced Oregon to take 3rd place.


That said, Dalia Frias (36th) capped her fantastic breakout season with an All-American honor -- she was awesome. With Mia Barnett (64th) and Anika Thompson (68th) closing out the team's top-six relatively quickly, I thought the Ducks should still be pretty happy with how they fared. Four All-Americans and six women in the top-70 is something to be proud of.


Oklahoma State Men Dominate, Score 57 Points En Route to NCAA Team Title Victory Over New Mexico

It seems fair to suggest that Oklahoma State, Iowa State and New Mexico were the three teams who we viewed as legitimate national title threats going into Saturday. And yet, despite that, most people seemed to lean in favor of Oklahoma State -- and that ended up being a good idea.


The Cowboys were flat-out dominant on Saturday. They eviscerated their opponents with an unreal amount of firepower and low-stick scoring, so much so that it reminded us of their 2023 national title win when they scored just 49 points.


Brian Musau (4th) and Denis Kipngetich (6th) were as good as expected, but Fouad Messaoudi (5th) shattered the lofty standard that he has set for himself throughout his career.


Oklahoma State men after winning the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay
Oklahoma State men after winning the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay

That ultra-elite scoring trio was complemented by Adisu Guadia (12th) who was arguably the biggest star of the day for the Pokes. Despite his career-long inconsistency, he came through in a major way far beyond what anyone expected out of him.


With Ryan Schoppe (34th) having the best cross country race of his life -- and finally delivering on his All-American upside -- there was no team in this field that could realistically touch Oklahoma State. That's an insane thing to say when you consider that runner-up New Mexico scored just 82 points in their own right.


This is now the fifth national team title that Coach Dave Smith has won with the Oklahoma State men. That's a substantial total which begins to put him among the NCAA all-time coaching greats in this sport as far as title counts are concerned.


Of course, we know how some people feel about that, specifically his unabashed lean on international athletes. But when it comes to taking advantage of the resources in front of him and ensuring that his recruited athletes are the best of the best of the best, few coaches in the NCAA have a better hit rate than Dave Smith -- and it's showing on a consistent basis.



As for New Mexico, I imagine they have a bittersweet feeling about their end result.


On one hand, a score of just 82 points would win many NCAA XC Championships. That's more than a great performance, it's an exceptional one. But on the other hand, I imagine the Lobo men would want to actually win the national title if they produced a score like that.


Even so, New Mexico has a lot to be proud of.


Habtom Samuel won the individual national title, Collins Kiprotich (8th) rebounded from a slow postseason to produce an elite performance and Evans Kiplagat (13th) elevated himself to a new tier of fitness that he's never been in before. With Vincent Chirchir (20th) delivering on expectations, the New Mexico men flexed an immense level of firepower that was overshadowed by a historical Oklahoma State effort.


Yes, it's true, the Lobos' fifth man, Mathew Kosgei, did fade back to 51st place. That final scoring spot was something that many of our TSR writers pointed to (in our preview) as a potential race decider in the national title battle.


And yet, it simply didn't matter.


Early stages of the men's race at the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay
Early stages of the men's race at the 2025 NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Andrew LeMay

Oklahoma State was too far ahead to be caught. Kosgei would have needed to place 19th overall for New Mexico to tie the Cowboys and 17th place overall for the Lobos to win said tie-breaker.


As for Iowa State, they ran very well on their own right, producing four All-Americans of their own. However, having only one guy crack the top-20 when Oklahoma State and New Mexico each had four effectively took them out of national title contention. It also didn't help that their fifth man, Sanele Masondo (86th), was rumored on the broadcast to have tripped on a hay bale during the race.




bottom of page