TSR's 2026 D3 XC Top 25 Individual Rankings (Women): Update #1

Written by Kevin Fischer, Conor Daly & Katie Hirsche
Edits and additional commentary via Garrett Zatlin & Gavin Struve
NOTE: These rankings are based on how an individual fared throughout the entirety of a season, not just how they ran at a singular meet or (eventually) at the 2026 NCAA XC Championships. Click here to learn more about our ranking criteria (which was published in 2023).
KEY
(Unranked):
Was not ranked in our last update.
(#/#):
First number indicates how much the athlete has moved in the rankings.
The second number indicates where the athlete was ranked in our last update.
25. Sydney Shock, Junior, Johns Hopkins (Unranked)
Given that she entered the season with a well-diversified resume of both cross country and track success, seeing Sydney Shock emerge as Johns Hopkins’ second runner does not come as too much of a surprise.
In her season opener at the Virginia Invitational, Shock was over 10 seconds better than she was a year ago over 5000 meters. This was encouraging to see before she took on more telling competition at the Running of the Cows.
In Northfield, the upperclassman delivered a lead-scoring performance for her team, crossing the line in 14th place. No, that run did not knock our socks off, but with experience on the national stage and consistency since March, Shock’s body of work and potential upside felt deserving of a shoutout in our rankings.
24. Isla Duncan, Freshman, Claremont-Mudd-Scripps (Unranked)
One of the newest Athenas is having a rookie campaign for the ages, especially for someone who we did not identify over the summer as having instant nationally competitive promise.
And based on everything we saw on her resume, that was a fair assessment.
That, however, has not seemed to matter to Isla Duncan, as she was beyond fantastic at the UC Riverside Invitational, where she placed 12th. But more importantly, she ran a time that was similar to that of now-graduated Claremont-Mudd-Scripps star Riley Capuano during the seasons when she would go on to be a top-half All-American.
The novice held her own at her biggest test yet at the Running of the Cows, something that is even more important to us. With a 13th place finish there, Duncan solidified the idea that she can be a top-half All-American this November and can execute in scary, talent-packed fields.
23. Morgan Eigel, Senior, Williams (-12 / 11)
After earning bronze over 3000 meters at the 2026 indoor national meet, Morgan Eigel has not emerged as a noticeably better runner this fall, at least not just yet.
She began her season with a forgivable "off" day at the Little Three XC Championships before rebounding at the Purple Valley XC Classic. On her home course, the senior looked to be in strong form, placing 3rd, only trailing two of her star teammates.
Those two relatively unimportant early season performances more or less canceled each other out.
Since then, her 18th place finish at the Running of the Cows was notably below expectations for the multi-time All-American. Yes, there is still reason to believe Eigel will be just as good as last year. However, with a mixed bag of performances this season, we need to drop her in our rankings because we are just none too sure what to expect anymore.
22. Kiera Tallas, Senior, Connecticut College (Unranked)
A breakout national qualifying spring season has translated to an exciting fall campaign for Kiera Tallas.
After winning a lightly contested season opener, the senior competed well against Division One programs to earn a 4th place finish at the UMass Dartmouth XC Invitational. Those were stepping stones to by far Tallas’ best cross country race of her career.
That, of course, came from a 12th place finish at the Running of the Cows amongst a few women we have already mentioned and many more we will in the coming paragraphs. That solidified the idea that Tallas can not only be an All-American, but can do so with room to spare.
21. Ingrid Norquist, Senior, Macalester (Unranked)
Now that we are digging into it, Ingrid Norquist had a sneaky-good cross country season last fall. A resume that features a 12th place finish at the Augustana Interregional Invitational and an 81st place finish at the NCAA XC Championships demands respect.
However, after not seeing Norquist on the track at all since then, the idea of her being an All-American this fall felt far-fetched.
That was, until the racing began.
A Minnesota local, Noquist took an early season win at the St. Olaf Ole Opener against a lightly contested field. However, the greatest development that came from that was the chance to see where she would be back for Running of the Cows in a few weeks' time.
That scouting clearly paid off, as the senior produced a logic-defying 10th place finish against a very good field.
Add in a second win of the season a few weeks prior to that Running of the Cows performance, and Norquist has seemingly thrived in every race scenario that has been placed in front of her.
20. Ellie Kozich, Junior, DeSales (0 / 20)
We’re not going to demote athletes who missed the chance to run at the Paul Short Run much, if at all, especially if their early-season form was inconclusive or solid.
Ellie Kozich broke out during the indoor track season, placing 6th over 5000 meters at the 2026 indoor national meet after a "last chance" qualifier. Despite a bit of a rough outdoor track season, we were high on her coming into the season.
We simply don’t have much data to work with for Kozich’s form so far, as she placed 7th at the 43rd Annual DeSales University XC Invitational in what was clearly an easier effort to open her season. We will wait to make any conclusions on Kozich’s fitness until she faces more competition with an all-in effort.
19. Breanna Schmitt, Senior, George Fox (Unranked)
After becoming a 38th place All-American at the 2024 cross country national meet, Breanna Schmitt only competed through the Paul Short Run (where she placed 27th in the “White” race) in the 2025 cross country season and didn’t run at all on the track earlier this year, so we weren’t sure where she stood coming into the 2026 fall season.
This fall, though, Schmitt has been lights-out. She was the runner-up behind an NAIA competitor at the PLU Invitational, giving us a good glimpse of her form. The Running of the Cows turned out to be the biggest and most successful test for Schmitt, as she went out in the top-three and held onto a top-10 spot the whole race, eventually crossing the finish line in 9th.
Among others, Schmitt beat out our TSR #9 runner, Kate Tuttle, an impressive feat that shows her great promise for the rest of the season.
18. Joley Berger, Junior, Ripon (Unranked)
Last spring was a banner season for Joley Berger, who dropped a massive amount of time off her 10k PR to run 35:20 and make the 2026 outdoor national meet, where she eventually placed 19th. Berger’s last result at the cross country national meet came in 2025, where she placed 131st, and she’ll likely crush that result if she keeps this form up.
She opened this season with a win at the Tom Barry Invitational, winning by nearly a minute, then placed 2nd among collegiate runners and first among Division Three runners at the Titan Fall Classic. However, she really showed off her new fitness at the Running of the Cows, placing 6th. Berger clearly is more comfortable in national-caliber fields after the 2025-26 academic year, which should help her next month.
17. Claire Palmer, Sophomore, Middlebury (-7 / 10)
Truth be told, we were looking for a bit more from Claire Palmer in the first two meets of her season. After a freshman year that nearly brought a top-half All-American result on the grass, Palmer seemed set for an even better sophomore year, and she still is in our estimation.
In the season-opening Aldrich Invitational, against Williams’ top squad, Palmer placed 6th, just behind teammate Annelise Jensen. That was a solid but not spectacular result. Palmer ran well at the Maribel Sanchez Souther Invitational, placing 16th, a better run that set her up for a strong Paul Short Run effort.
Of course, she didn't get that chance, with her race being canceled. Even so, she'll soon run with the Panthers at the Connecticut College Invitational, and that will be a huge test.
16. Stella Kuttner, Junior, NYU (0 / 16)
We’re remiss to remove any NYU athletes from our rankings considering that they haven’t had a chance to really show what they can do this season, so Stella Kuttner stays where she is.
Kuttner placed 7th at the Vassar Season Starter over 3000 meters in the only meet of her season so far. That was a good result, but one that makes it unclear where her fitness is really at. It will be a few more weeks before we can really get a read on where Kuttner shakes out this season.
15. April Schilling, Senior, Connecticut College (Unranked)
Should we give her our "Most Improved Runner" award already?
Ok...maybe not yet.
Entering the fall, April Schilling was arguably not even a top-100 name in the country. Her best performance last fall was likely a 37th place finish at the Mideast Regional XC Championships. On the track, 2:16 (800) and 5:11 (mile) performances are solid, but not nationally competitive, nor do they suggest success over the 6k distance.
But none of that logic seems to matter this fall. In her first two races of the season, Schilling was a strong second scorer for the Camels.
But that was merely the tip of the iceberg, as the senior broke through in an unbelievable way with a 4th place finish at the Running of the Cows. That is simply too good to be considered a fluke and raises her ceiling to a height we never dreamed possible.
14. Grace Rowley, Junior, NYU (0 / 14)
Has not raced yet this season.
13. Ashlyn Pallotta, Sophomore, NYU (0 / 13)
Even though Ashlyn Pallotta ran a conservative 3000-meter season-opening effort, she has not truly raced in any meaningful fashion this season. As such, the defending UAA cross country champion does not budge from TSR #13 in our rankings.
12. Madison Hedglin, Sophomore, Misericordia (+3 / 15)
After a star freshman year, Madison Hedglin continues to be an individual standout for an oftentimes forgotten Misericordia program.
In her first two races of the season, she was hardly challenged at a pair of home meets, taking comfortable wins in each. She faced greater competition at the Lock Haven University XC Invitational, where she earned bronze. However, Hedglin did not face any notable Division Three competition there, making her true fitness still a bit of an unknown.
Considering she is not attending the Connecticut College Invitational, nor does she have a competitive conference, this uncertainty may be the case for the foreseeable future. Ultimately, she moves up in our rankings in part because of the struggles of others who were previously ranked ahead of her.
11. Katja Dunayevich, Sophomore, U. of Chicago (+7 / 18)
Even if she has not gone head-to-head with any of the Goliaths of Division Three yet this season, Katja Dunayevich has done no wrong in her three outings so far this fall.
She broke the tape at the Saints Twilight Invite and Gil Dodds Invitational, where she did not face any runners that could realistically threaten her. However, that was not the case in the Joe Piane Invitational “Gold” race. There, Dunayevich logged a strong 10th place finish against a field that mainly featured women from outside of the Division Three circuit.
Her 17:31 (5k) mark there was quite quick for the grass, but the real resume boost came from the fact that it was over 15 seconds quicker than she ran at that meet a year ago! That points to the sophomore being ready to be considered one of the premier names not only in the Midwest region, but in the country, too.
10. Tamar Byl, Senior, Williams (+2 / 12)
As an already-proven cross country star, Tamar Byl has filled that same role this season for the national championship-contending Ephs.
In what has been a busy beginning of the season, Byl first placed 4th at the Little Three Championships over 4000 meters before placing 2nd at the Purple Valley XC Classic over the full 6k distance. And while those placements may seem a bit further back for a top-10 runner in the country, you need to remember just how good her teammates are.
The veteran’s biggest test this season came at the Running of the Cows. There, she placed 8th amongst the stacked nationally competitive field, largely meeting expectations.
Sure, we might be ranking Byl ahead of women who beat her head-to-head that day, but her steadiness is a huge plus, as is her multi-time All-American resume that has proven she can maintain this level.
9. Kate Tuttle, Junior, Williams (-2 / 7)
Coming off of a shrug-inducing cross country season, but a jaw-dropping track campaign, during her sophomore year, Kate Tuttle’s 2026 fall campaign has trended closer to her track successes so far.
Season-opening wins against her star teammates at the Little Three Invitational and the Aldrich Invitational were huge for seeing her return to elite form on the grass, especially when you consider that she beat defending national champion Audrey Maclean in the latter effort. Tuttle took down some of the best names in the country, and it did not come as too much of a surprise, truthfully.
Unfortunately, seeing Tuttle run below expectations to place 11th at the Running of the Cows, in by far her biggest test of the season, does require us to weigh that against her. Sure, this may be something that both Tuttle and we will look back on by the end of the season as a fluke "off" day, but considering her history of some variability on the grass, we were forced to take this downturn a bit more seriously.
8. Charlie Flint, Senior, Colorado College (+11 / 19)
After a strong junior cross country season, Charlie Flint was held back in our Running of the Cows predictions after having a "just okay" track season. However, in that effort, she proved that what happened on the oval is secondary and that she is one of the top D3 runners in the country.
There, she recorded by far the best result of her career with a huge bronze medal-worthy performance. She only lost to a cross country national meet runner-up and a star freshman who is running out of her mind at the moment.
In this run, Flint unlocked a ceiling we did not think possible for her this fall and forces us to consider how close to the national title favorites she can get. Her pedigree did not quite suggest that she could pull off something like that, but by no means did it come out of the blue, either.
7. Lucinda Laughlin, Junior, Washington U. (-2 / 5)
Following her outstanding sophomore track seasons, we were expecting a nice progression from Lucinda Laughlin. And after she ran 4:17 (1500) and 16:24 (5k), how could you blame us?
The cross country upside that we envisioned has not come to fruition just yet, but Laughlin is also not far from it. Her season-opening performance at the John McNichols Invitational did not really move the needle for us, as we saw the Running of the Cows as a better fitness check.
In Minnesota, Laughlin held her own with a 7th place finish against a very talented field, delivering an impactful low-stick performance for the Bears. We are still clinging to her track PRs that suggest there’s some more meat on the bone, but even if there’s not, the Bears’ leader is still comfortably a top-15 name in the country.
6. Carter Brotherton, Junior, Johns Hopkins (+2 / 8)
The leader of the Blue Jays is making a case for herself as one of the most consistent runners both from race to race as well as from season to season.
In her season opener at the Virginia Invitational, Brotherton performed well, suggesting she is on track for another successful season. Her exact time was 10 seconds slower than she ran there last year before she went on to place 10th at the cross country national meet, but this is within the margin of error that keeps her more or less on the same trajectory.
Her more telling performance came at the Running of the Cows, where she placed 5th in a field that featured the majority of the women within the top-10 of our rankings. And while that was good as is, it’s nice to realize that a 3rd place finish was within 15 meters at the finish.
5. Josephine Dziedzic, Senior, NYU (+1 / 6)
Very little to report from New York City.
Josephine Dziedzic has only contested a 3000-meter race at the Vassar Season Starter, where she put forth a conservative effort to finish in a pack with her teammates.
The cancellation of the Paul Short Run stripped us of an opportunity to see the veteran star put her best foot forward. At this point, we expect her to be in excellent form in her next race.
4. Sophie Capozzi, Freshman, Williams (Unranked)
Before setting foot in Williamstown, Massachusetts, we knew Sophie Capozzi would be good. After all, she had run 9:54 (3k) and had placed 22nd at the 2025 NXR Northwest meet, among other performances that indicated she would be a star in the years to come.
And even despite respecting her talents, Capozzi has blown away our expectations as one of the top talents in the nation in each of her first three races in purple. At the Aldrich Invitational, Capozzi beat some of the top individual talents in the country, like Middlebury’s Audrey Maclean and Claire Palmer, placing 2nd only behind teammate Kate Tuttle.
The next week, she safely won the Purple Valley XC Invitational over star teammates Tamar Byl and Morgan Eigel.
Her Northeast dominance extended to Minnesota when she faced by far her greatest test at the Running of the Cows. Against some of the best teams and individuals in the country, the rookie finished runner-up, only falling to national title contender (and arguably even title favorite) Haley Schoenegge. In the process, Capozzi took the scalps of women who are far more experienced and have numerous All-American honors and red-hot personal bests to their name.
Amidst a dream freshman season, Capozzi must be in the national title picture after beating numerous superstars over the past month.
3. Olivia Warr, Senior, Washington and Lee (+1 / 4)
This two-time top-10 finisher at the cross country national meet looks poised to reach that status for the third year in a row.
After a successful track season in which she found greater success over the longer distances, Olivia Warr has performed well in a pair of races on a challenging Virginia Tech course. Sure, she did not race any meaningful Division Three competition at either of those races, but they were encouraging measuring sticks of her current form.
Unfortunately, a DNF at the Richmond Invitational leaves some smidge of lingering concern, although that is not something we are particularly focused on at this point.
2. Haley Schoenegge, Senior, Vassar (0 / 2)
After being the cross country national meet runner-up in 2024, last fall looked like Haley Schoenegge’s time to shine and potentially take home the Division Three crown. However, her season last fall was not quite up to expectations.
With a 2026 track season that blew us away, we figured that Schoenegge would be excellent this fall and match her 2024 heights. That could not have rung more true in her dominant win at Running of the Cows, where her mid-race surge paid off en route to a 10-second victory. In doing so, she comfortably beat six women who are ranked in our top-10.
At this point, Schoenegge is in the national title picture as much as she ever has been. Truthfully, if you wanted to call her the favorite at this point, we would not argue with you.
1. Audrey MacLean, Senior, Middlebury (0 / 1)
The first few weeks of the season have been revealing for the defending cross country national champion who spent the spring abroad.
In her season opener at the Aldrich Invitational, Audrey MacLean settled for 3rd place behind Williams’ Kate Tuttle and Sophie Capozzi. And while it would have been ideal if Maclean pulled out the win, both members of that Williams duo are top-10 runners in the country.
At the Maribel Sanchez Souther Invitational, MacLean (8th) stamped another solid performance amongst a Division One-dominated front pack.
While at least one D3 woman has had a better 2026 cross country season than MacLean, we are giving her the respect that the defending national champion (by over 45 seconds) deserves.
ADDED
Sophie Capozzi (Williams)
April Schilling (Connecticut College)
Joley Berger (Ripon)
Breanna Schmitt (George Fox)
Ingrid Norquist (Macalester)
Kiera Tallas (Connecticut College)
Isla Duncan (Claremont-Mudd-Scripps)
Sydney Shock (Johns Hopkins)
KICKED OFF
Jules Bleskoski (RPI)
Mia Kotler (Johns Hopkins)
Molly Heidorn (UW-Eau Claire)
Molly Novotny (UW-La Crosse)
Maya Ducker (Carnegie Mellon)
Sadie Drucker (Claremont-Mudd-Scripps)
Sofia Moukaddem (Suffolk)
Liv Girand (MIT)
JUST MISSED (in no particular order)
Mia Kotler (Johns Hopkins)
Molly Heidorn (UW-Eau Claire)
Molly Novotny (UW-La Crosse)
Sadie Drucker (Claremont-Mudd-Scripps)
Sofia Moukaddem (Suffolk)
Keelee Leitzen (Loras)
Faith Wehrman (UW-Stevens Point)
Kathryn Arbegast (RIT)
Elise Kempf (Carnegie Mellon)
Ananya Devpura (Carnegie Mellon)
HONORABLE MENTIONS (in no particular order)
Maya Ducker (Carnegie Mellon)
Liv Girand (MIT)
Zoe Ward (Ohio Wesleyan)
Madison Twarling (UW-La Crosse)
Jocelyn Onstot (Rose-Hulman)
Claudia Lasiowski (UW-Stout)
Lily Simmonds (Tufts)
Annelise Jensen (Middlebury)
Chesnee Miller (Manchester)
Delisha Davis (Dubuque)
Ester Zar (Batten)
Notes
- Jules Bleskoski (preseason TSR #3) is no longer listed on RPI's roster. As such, she's been removed from our rankings.
.png)


