TSR's 2026 D3 Indoor Top 25 Individual Rankings (Women): Update #1

Written by Kevin Fischer and Conor Daly
Edits and additional commentary via Gavin Struve
NOTE: These rankings are based on how an individual fared throughout the entirety of a season, not just how they ran at a singular meet or (eventually) at the 2026 NCAA Indoor Championships.
KEY
(Unranked):
Was not ranked in our last update.
(#/#):
The first number indicates how much the individual has moved in the rankings.
The second number indicates where the individual was ranked in our last update.
25. Krystal Montgomery, Senior, MIT (0 / 25)
While Krystal Montgomery has had plenty of success moving down to 400 meters in the past, she tested out her aerobic strength a bit with a 1000-meter effort at the Beantown Challenge this past Saturday.
Even if her 1000-meter mark of 2:57 wasn’t necessarily eye-popping, it’s hard to be too critical of her. Montgomery is probably the most speed-oriented athlete in our rankings, and going up to the longest distance that she has contested in the collegiate ranks was always going to be a challenge.
All things considered, Montgomery held her own pretty well and remains in our rankings ahead of her first 800-meter effort of the season.
24. Gabriella Nye, Senior, Widener (0 / 24)
At the Alvernia Winter Invitational this past weekend, Gabriella Nye took the mile win in 5:02 over cross country All-American, Madison Hedglin. She then doubled back to win the 800 meters. While that was a solid pair of results, it wasn't quite at the level that we saw her operating at last spring.
Of course, once she gets to the national stage, it’s hard to imagine Nye not being highly competitive. With that said, she will likely need to run a bit quicker over the next six weeks or so to reach that starting line. Even so, she has earned plenty of grace in our rankings, given what she has accomplished in the last two years.
23. Lexi Fernandez, Senior, MIT (0 / 23)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
22. Stella Kuttner, Sophomore, NYU (0 / 22)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
21. Josephine Dziedzic, Junior, NYU (0 / 21)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
20. Chloe Bonson, Senior, Carnegie Mellon (0 / 20)
Has not yet competed this season.
19. Rujuta Sane, Senior, MIT (0 / 19)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
18. Bailey Puckett, Senior, Trine (0 / 18)
Bailey Puckett has run everything but her primary event, the mile, this winter. She opened with a sub-10:00 (3k) PR last month and then ran a half-mile and a 5k this past weekend, winning the former and placing 3rd in the latter. If fine-tuning her skillset in "off" events is what Puckett needs to produce her first All-American honor, then it will all have been worth it.
17. Carter Brotherton, Sophomore, Johns Hopkins (0 / 17)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
16. Claire Anderson, Senior, Washington & Jefferson (0 / 16)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
15. Janie Cooper, Senior, NYU (-1 / 14)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
14. Sophie Bull, Senior, Calvin (-1 / 13)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
13. Kate Sanderson, Senior, MIT (-1 / 12)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
12. Alexa Estes, Senior, Connecticut College (+3 / 15)
A little over a week ago, Alexa Estes opened up her indoor track season with an "off" distance. On a flat track at the Wesleyan Winter Invitational, the veteran won the 1000 meters in a solid time of 2:56 over star miler and teammate, Grace McDonough.
For the beginning of December, this is a fantastic place to be. Already with four trips to the national meet over 800 meters, it feels like it’s about time that Estes reaps the reward of her consistent success. At this rate, any combination of a breakthrough personal best, numerous race wins or a fantastic national meet placement would not surprise us.
11. Madison Tiaffay, Senior, Emory (0 / 11)
Has not yet competed this season.
10. Annika Paluska, Sophomore, Williams (0 / 10)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
9. Kate Tuttle, Sophomore, Williams (-3 / 6)
After a somewhat unsteady cross country season, Kate Tuttle has since been in great form on the track. The Ephs’ star just clocked a 4:58 (mile) on a flat track at the Middlebury Winter Classic. In that race, Tuttle finished a narrow 2nd behind her All-American teammate Morgan Eigel.
It’s hard to project that Tuttle will defend her silver medal in the mile that she earned at last year’s indoor national meet, but it’s safe to say that she’s in fantastic form as an All-American favorite. With terrific range, as her 16:50 (5k) from December suggests, Tuttle is a threat over the mile, the 3k and the 5k, something that few women can claim to the same degree.
8. Adriana Catalano, Senior, Johns Hopkins (+1 / 9)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
7. Olivia Warr, Junior, Washington and Lee (+1 / 8)
Has not yet competed this season.
6. Gillian Roeder, Senior, MIT (+1 / 7)
Has not yet competed this season.
5. Kayla Kass, Senior, Stockton (0 / 5)
Seeking her sixth track national meet appearance and fourth All-American honor, Kayla Kass hasn’t shown her hand just yet.
In her season opener at the NYC Gotham Cup, Kass ran 1:20.35 (500) before splitting a 59.13 (400) anchor leg on her team’s 4x400-meter relay. For someone who has run faster than that 500-meter pace for a full half-mile, Kass doesn't seem to be at her sharpest just yet.
However, she didn’t wow us up to this point last year and ended up being the 6th-best 800-meter runner at the 2025 indoor national meet. As such, we are willing to give her the benefit of the doubt for now.
4. Amelia Lehman, Senior, UW-Oshkosh (0 / 4)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
3. Grace McDonough, Senior, Connecticut College (0 / 3)
This mile superstar opened up her season with a 1000-meter on Wesleyan’s flat indoor track. There, she showed us that she’s slightly ahead of schedule, with a 2:56 clocking. A runner-up finish was strong, with McDonough just barely getting out-leaned by her highly accomplished teammate, Alexa Estes.
It’s encouraging to see McDonough successfully run an event at the shorter end of her range. Her 13th-place finish at the 2025 NCAA XC Championships proved that she’s aerobically stronger than ever. To couple that fitness with still-strong turnover is a recipe for success for someone who was a three-time top-three finisher at the NCAA Championships in 2025.
2. Jules Bleskoski, Junior, RPI (0 / 2)
Has not yet competed this season.
1. Haley Schoenegge, Junior, Vassar (0 / 1)
Has not competed since our last rankings update.
ADDED
N/A
KICKED OFF
N/A
JUST MISSED (in no particular order)
Morgan Eigel (Williams)
Grace Rowley (NYU)
Claire Palmer (Middlebury)
Hannah Preisser (Carleton)
Peyton Steffen (Central College)
Sierra Doody (SUNY Geneseo)
Hannah Stephenson (Amherst)
Isabel Wyatt (St. Olaf)
Lucinda Laughlin (Washington U.)
Gabriella Pagano (Rowan)
HONORABLE MENTIONS (in no particular order)
Mia Kotler (Johns Hopkins)
Adriana Crabtree (Illinois Wesleyan)
Tamar Byl-Brann (Williams)
Riley Capuano (Claremont-Mudd-Scripps)
Elizabeth Donahue (Tufts)
Molly Durow (Hope)
Molly Fitzgibbons (Rochester)
Emma Kothari (Johns Hopkins)
Erin vonHousen (RPI)
Piper Lentz (Amherst)
Nora Holmes (U. of Chicago)
Elle Marsyla (Claremont-Mudd-Scripps)
Ashlyn Pallota (NYU)
Lauren Walda (St. Olaf)
Notes
- N/A
.png)


