top of page

TSR's 2026 D2 Indoor Top 25 Individual Rankings (Women): Update #2

TSR Collaboration
Feb 3
12 min read

Written by Jaime Diedel & Gavin Struve

Edits and additional commentary via Gavin Struve

 NOTE: These rankings are based on how an individual fared throughout the entirety of a season, not just how they ran at a singular meet or (eventually) at the 2026 NCAA Indoor Championships.

KEY

(Unranked):

Was not ranked in our last update.


(#/#):

The first number indicates how much the individual has moved in the rankings.

The second number indicates where the individual was ranked in our last update.

25. Sarah Koomson, Senior, West Texas A&M (0 / 25)

At the midpoint of this season, it appears Sarah Koomson has made the full pivot into being a middle distance runner on the track.


Her only two non-relay races this season have been mile efforts. Don't forget that she sparked her career revival over 1500 meters last spring, where she earned her first All-American honor in a year and a half.


Her 4:58 mile at the Corky Classic earlier this month wasn't the greatest opener, given that she lost to two teammates, but Koomson was the fastest Buffalo this past weekend when she ran 4:54 for a narrow collegiate runner-up finish at the New Mexico Team Open. That effort at just under 5000 feet of altitude earned her a 4:48 conversion, which puts her at NCAA #10 (D2) in the mile this season.


Moving forward, it will be interesting to monitor whether Koomson moves up in distance or focuses on earning her first mile All-American honor.


24. Allison Beasley, Senior, Western Colorado (-3 / 21)

Allison Beasley's 10:17 mark to win the 3k at her home meet last week wasn't eye-popping, but it earned her a 9:41 conversion. She may have to run a bit faster to secure her spot at the indoor national meet in that event, but Beasley appears close to her best form through just two races this season.


That should be scary for her opposition, given that she's a seven-time All-American and the 5th-place finisher from the 2025 cross country national meet. For now, Beasley's solid showing in an easy win was enough to keep her in our rankings.


23. Ellie Frye, Senior, Dallas Baptist (-3 / 20)

Faced with greater opposition at the Boston U. John Thomas Terrier Classic, Ellie Frye didn't run quite as fast over 800 meters as she did in her season opener nearly two months ago.


Even so, a 2:10 clocking, two seconds slower than her season's best, is nothing to be ashamed of. Plus, Frye ran a 5:01 mile PR last week.


The Dallas Baptist veteran remains one of the most experienced 800-meter runners on the national stage. And by sitting at NCAA #7 in that event this season, she appears to be very much in line to return to that setting. Her three-spot drop in these rankings shouldn't be overanalyzed.


Ellie Frye competing over 800m at the Boston U. Season Opener // Photo via Nick Alvarado
Ellie Frye competing over 800m at the Boston U. Season Opener // Photo via Nick Alvarado

22. Jadyn Herron, Senior, CSU-Pueblo (+2 / 24)

After starting with a 3000-meter run and a modest mile effort, middle distance specialist Jadyn Herron really ramped up her performances over last two weeks. She ran a 4:53 mile time at altitude last week and returned to Albuquerque, New Mexico this past weekend for a 2:13 (800) run.


That mile mark earned Herron a 4:47 conversion and makes it seem likely that she'll pursue the mile at the indoor national meet after running the 1500 meters at the 2025 NCAA Outdoor Championships (following consecutive national meet appearances in the half-mile).


If she's gaining momentum at the right time like we think she is, and is able to lean on her past experience, then this ThunderWolf veteran could be quietly dangerous come March.


21. Allie Arnsman, Junior, Grand Valley State (Unranked)

It's possible that this ranking is underselling Allie Arnsman. She's in line to qualify for the indoor national meet in two different events and just finished one spot ahead of superstar teammate Lauren Kiley over 3000 meters this past weekend.


For reference, Kiley is the defending national champion in that event.


Arnsman's 9:32 (3k) clocking sits at NCAA #8 in D2 this winter, but she also ran a 16:31 (5k) PR in an event that she placed 12th in at the 2025 indoor national meet. A 4:54 mile PR last week indicated that both her speed and strength are at all-time highs.


In our defense of this placement towards the bottom of our top-25 rankings, Arnsman has raced at just one national meet on the track and has never been an All-American outside of cross country season. However, that should be in line to change given the steady trajectory she's followed throughout her collegiate career.



20. Evie Brooks, Junior, Wingate (+2 / 22)

For being someone who was a 2025 mile national qualifier and one spot away from All-American honors over 1500 meters last year, it's surprising that Evie Brooks hasn't run the mile yet this winter.


She's made that seem like the right decision, however, in running a 9:37 (3k) PR in December and then dropping a 2:13 (800) mark this weekend before doubling back to further lower her 3k PR to 9:28. That latter mark sits at NCAA #6 in D2 this season, and it makes sense that the speedster is focusing on that distance after comfortably earning All-American honors this past fall.


Regardless of whether she makes herself a national threat in the mile as well, Brooks looks like one of the most complete 3k runners in Division Two right now.


19. Charlotte Young, Junior, CSU-Pueblo (Unranked)

Meet CSU-Pueblo's newest half-mile star: Charlotte Young.


The still-rising British runner will look to follow in the footsteps of her countrywoman-turned-teammate, Helen Braybrook, as a middle distance star. Young opened with a solid 4:58 altitude-converted mile, but then ran 2:08 and 2:10 (800) marks at altitude in back-to-back weekends to close out January.


Young was the third-fastest collegian in both races, ahead of a number of D1 runners. And given how well she's acquitted herself in her first year of NCAA competition, this junior may be D2's most likely first-time 800-meter All-American come March.


Charlotte Young charging to the finish line at the NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Jackie Kirby
Charlotte Young charging to the finish line at the NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Jackie Kirby

18. Allison Kuzma, Sophomore, Hillsdale (-2 / 16)

Even if it didn't guarantee her a spot in the event at the indoor national meet, Allison Kuzma's 9:48 (3k) mark in a 45-second win last week was impressive. That complemented her 16:19 (5k) PR from December, when she outran reigning NCAA 3k champion Lauren Kiley on Kiley's home track.


Kuzma was always going to be better-suited for the longer distances, given that she broke out in the 10k last spring. Even so, the fact that she's faring so well in her second collegiate indoor track season is worthy of some praise despite her two-spot drop.


17. Abigail Bester, Freshman, Wingate (+1 / 18)

Even if she didn't necessarily improve her stock (much) since our last rankings update, Abigail Bester is in a great spot. After all, her 3k and 5k marks from December remain in the top five on the D2 national leaderboard!


Most recently, Bester ran a 4:59 mile PR. That's not close to as competitive as her marks in the two longer events, but Bester still has a clear case as the best freshman long distance runner in Division Two right now.


16. Maggie McCleskey, Senior, Adams State (-6 / 10)

While a 4:49 altitude-converted mile is impressive on its own, we expected a bit more from Maggie McCleskey last weekend. That time put her 10 seconds behind her two teammates at the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr Invitational. After all, McCleskey has been a mile All-American each of the past two seasons.


This drop in our rankings is also reflection of how impressive a handful of other D2 women were over the last couple of weekends. All things considered, it was challenging to keep McCleskey in our top-15.


Nonetheless, she is sitting at a respectable NCAA #13 (D2) spot in that event this season and remains at NCAA #5 (D2) over 3000 meters after beating Allison Beasley (TSR #24) by 20 seconds with a sub-9:30 conversion early this winter.



15. Hannah Hartwell, Rs. Senior, Fort Lewis (-2 / 13)

Hannah Hartwell eschewed what was a slow start to the season by her standards with a strong weekend in Albuquerque, New Mexico to close out the month.


The Fort Lewis veteran ran 9:42 to win the 3k at the New Mexico Team Open, out-running Naomi Addo by 10 seconds. She also clocked a 4:54 mile PR at the same meet, beating several other West Texas A&M stars to again serve as the top collegian.


Hartwell now has top-10 marks nationally in both the mile and the 3k, while also residing in the top-20 over 5k. Needless to say, the reigning NCAA indoor 5k bronze medalist is rounding into form at the right time. Her drop in our rankings is more so the result of others in D2 rather than anything she has done.


14. Kiara Bester, Freshman, Wingate (+5 / 19)

Running a 4:51 mile PR gave Kiara Bester the best-of-three edge over her twin sister, Abigail Bester, so far this season. She beat Abigail by one second over 3000 meters, was two seconds slower over 5000 meters and then was eight seconds faster in the mile this past weekend.


Kiara Bester is now a top-15 runner in D2 in three different distance events, an unprecedented level of range for a rookie. Her youth-based upside makes her incredibly dangerous and we're beginning to see how high her ceiling can rise in 2026.


Kiara Bester competing at the NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Jackie Kirby
Kiara Bester competing at the NCAA XC Championships // Photo via Jackie Kirby

13. Paige Mullen, Junior, Pittsburg State (+1 / 14)

A 9th-place finish over 3000 meters at the 2025 indoor national meet put Paige Mullen on the map. Naturally, we expected her to return to that event after a top-10 finish at the 2025 NCAA XC Championships.


The Pittsburg State junior opened her 2026 winter campaign with a 16:09 (5k) PR in December and was just as impressive with a 9:35 (3k) mark en route to a win last weekend. Mullen took down a solid field of conference competition on her home track, running one of the 10 fastest Division Two 3k times this season while holding off three other women who finished within eight seconds of her.


That kind of close win bodes well with tight postseason races looming. Experience, momentum and tactical success are all on her side at the perfect time of the year.


12. Lauren Kiley, Senior, Grand Valley State (-6 / 6)

Try not to mistake this drop in our rankings as an insult to the defending 3000-meter national champion. After all, Lauren Kiley is listed in the top 10 of D2 in two events so far this winter. However, there were other results since our last rankings update that deserved a bump up in position.


Nonetheless, at the GVSU Bill Clinger Invitational, Kiley dropped a 4:53 mile for a 3rd-place finish. Considering the senior is a 4:45 miler at her best, that was another good, but not necessarily great, showing.


This past weekend at the Meyo Invitational at Notre Dame, the Laker ace took 18th over 3000 meters in a fairly stacked Division One field. Kiley’s time of 9:34 landed her at NCAA #9 in the event among D2 women as we enter February. She did, however, lose to teammate Allie Arnsman, who set a new personal best over 3000 meters only a couple of seconds ahead. 


Armed with a strong 5k time from December (which was closer to her personal best), Kiley finds herself in a decent spot entering February. She remains in the top-half of our rankings, and our guess is that this will be her low point.


11. Raiya Matonovich, Freshman, Simon Fraser (+6 / 17)

Freshman Raiya Matonovich has made a big jump in our rankings thanks to her stellar middle distance performances. Let’s cut right to it!


In mid-January, the rookie produced the current NCAA #5 (D2) time in the mile with her 4:42 clocking. Most recently in Boston, Matonovich covered the half-mile distance in a head-turning 2:08. Not only is that the NCAA #8 (D2) mark this winter, but it saw her take the victory in the Boston U. John Thomas Terrier Classic's "Open" section over multiple BIG 12 and ACC runners, as well as D3 title contender in Annika Paluska.


Even as a freshman, Matonovich has made it clear she’s not only fast, but she has the competitive prowess needed to be successful against upper-tier competition. That fact has her already brushing up against the top 10 of our rankings.



10. Grace Strongman, Rs. Senior, Colorado Mines (+2 / 12)

Hasn't competed since our last rankings update.


9. Emily LaMena, Rs. Sophomore, Colorado Mines (+2 / 11)

Hasn't competed since our last rankings update.


8. Jade Avance, Senior, Ashland (+1 / 9)

Jade Avance had herself quite the past two weeks over 800 meters.


The Eagle veteran won the Ashland Invitational by a landslide in an impressive 2:09 (800) clocking. Even better, a week later, Avance produced a 2:07 mark, which is now NCAA #4 among D2 women for this indoor track season.


Avance hasn't lost to any D2 competition in her signature event through three tries this season. Not only that, but she's gotten progressively faster since starting with a 2:10 (800) victory in December.


Her continued progression is nothing short of encouraging, bumping the reigning NCAA outdoor 800-meter bronze medalist up one spot to TSR #8.


Jade Avance competing over 800m at the NCAA Outdoor Championships // Photo via Jackie Kirby
Jade Avance competing over 800m at the NCAA Outdoor Championships // Photo via Jackie Kirby

7. Annie Wild, Junior, Stanislaus State (-3 / 4)

Hasn't competed since our last rankings update. 


6. Aria Hawkins, Senior, Lee (Tenn.) (+2 / 8)

Producing a second top-six time on the D2 national leaderboard is one way to move up in TSR's rankings!


Aria Hawkins had herself a day in Boston this past weekend, running 4:45 in the full mile -- and a 4:26 (1500) split, en route. The senior has always been spectacular over 3000 meters, running 9:15 (3k) earlier this season and taking bronze in that event at last year’s indoor national meet. However, Hawkins isn't far off in the mile. Consider that she's twice been a top-10 finisher in the NCAA 1500-meter final.


Hawkins’ range and reliability continue to move her up in our rankings and land her just outside the top five. Her experience is clearly going to benefit her in March and right now, she is seems plenty prepared to face high-end competition at the NCAA Indoor Championships.



5. Lieke Hoogsteen, Senior, Adams State (+2 / 7)

Welcome to the top five, Lieke Hoogsteen!


The 800-meter specialist did her thing at the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr Invitational. She produced an altitude converted time of 2:06 for the half-mile distance, which currently puts her at NCAA #3 in the event. More impressively, Hoogsteen outperformed our TSR #1 runner -- the reigning NCAA indoor 800-meter champion -- by over a second in that race!


Also holding a solid 4:49 altitude-converted mile from back in December, Hoogsteen has proven to be very versatile this season, and this ranking may even be underselling her despite moving her up.


4. Abigail Abugire, Sophomore, West Texas A&M (+1 / 5)

Abigail Abugire produced an NCAA lead over 800 meters this past weekend. That should come as little surprise, but an altitude-converted time of 2:05 will definitely turn some heads.


Abugire took the win over Helen Braybrook by less than half a second en route to her top Division Two mark. A win is a win nonetheless, and it's arguably more impressive that Abugire held Braybrook off when both were firing on all cylinders or close to it.


Considering she also won the 2025 NCAA outdoor 800-meter title, is Abugire now the title favorite for the 800 meters this winter?


Abigail Abugire celebrates as she wins the NCAA D2 outdoor 800m title // Photo via Jackie Kirby
Abigail Abugire celebrates as she wins the NCAA D2 outdoor 800m title // Photo via Jackie Kirby

3. Tristian Spence, Junior, Adams State (0 / 3)

Reigning cross country national champion Tristian Spence put together a statement mile performance at the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. Invitational -- her first race since her season-opening 5k PR of 15:50 (NCAA #1 in D2) back in December. 


Spence not only almost matched her 4:45 PR, but she earned an altitude-converted time of 4:40 -- that is the NCAA #3 mark in D2 this season. She's now a national title contender in three different events, although we've yet to see her challenge her 9:07 (3k) PR yet this season.


2. Ava O'Connor, Rs. Senior, Adams State (0 / 2)

Two weekends ago, we saw Ireland native Ava O’Connor toe the line for the first time since early December. She stepped down in distance since her all-time 3000-meter run, this time contesting the mile. 


At nearly 5000 feet above sea level, O’Connor was the first Division Two woman across the finish line, in 4:42. That time converted to a 4:36 full mile, which put her at NCAA #2 (D2) in the event this season, only behind NCAA D2 record holder, Helen Braybrook.


Though she’s only raced twice this season, O’Connor has produced two mighty results, an NCAA #1 (3k) mark and an NCAA #2 (mile) mark, holding her steady at TSR #2, but not far from our top spot.


1. Helen Braybrook, Senior, CSU-Pueblo (0 / 1)

While there was a bit of debate, it shouldn't come as a major surprise to see superstar Helen Braybrook at the top of our rankings once again. Since our last rankings update, Braybrook tested her 800-meter speed and even stepped down to a 600-meter race and a 4x400-meter relay.


At the Dr. Martin Luther King Jr Invitational, the CSU-Pueblo senior ran 2:08 (800) and 1:31 (600) at almost 5000 feet of elevation. The only collegian in front of Braybrook was Adams State’s Lieke Hoogsteen (TSR #5).


This past weekend, Braybrook ran another impressive altitude-converted 800-meter time (2:06), which landed her at NCAA #2 (D2). It was faster than what she or Hoogsteen ran on the same track one week earlier, but Braybrook was once again not the fastest D2 woman in the field. She lost to Abigail Abugire (TSR #4).


Braybrook has been very beatable over 800 meters to the point that she may not be the favorite. At the same time, her 4:30 mile mark is unprecedented at the D2 level, and her versatility this season has us content leaving her at TSR #1.

ADDED

Charlotte Young (CSU-Pueblo)

Allie Arnsman (Grand Valley State)


KICKED OFF

Emily Walsh (Cedarville)

Claire Rethman (Walsh)


JUST MISSED (in no particular order)

Peyton Weiss (Western Colorado)

Naomi Addo (West Texas A&M)

Abby VanderKooi (Grand Valley State)

Lexi Herr (Colorado Mines)

Sierra Wall (Colorado Mines)

Margaux Basart (Colorado Mines)

Rachael Watkins (Simon Fraser)

Abigail Misch (Flagler)

Kiki Witt (NW Missouri)

Addison Washler (Grand Valley State)


HONORABLE MENTIONS (in no particular order)

Emily Walsh (Cedarville)

Claire Rethman (Walsh)

Lauren Willson (Western Colorado)

Isabel Perez-Zoghbi (Cal Poly Humboldt)

Marie Dea (NW Missouri)

Karlijn Mesman (Wingate)

Lauren Wallace (Mississippi College)

Kalkidan Vincendeau (West Texas A&M)

Claragh Keane (Adams State)

Maddie Miller-Ross (Illinois-Springfield)

Emily McCullough (Fort Hays State)

Hannah Gibson (Pittsburg State)

Amy Morefield (Rogers State)

Daisy Speet (Grand Valley State)

Lexie Fontaine (Washburn)


Notes

- N/A




bottom of page