top of page

TSR's 2025-26 D1 Current Freshman Class Rankings: #10-9-8 (Men)

Writer: Admin (Garrett Zatlin)
Admin (Garrett Zatlin)
Jan 6
8 min read

Despite our research, it is possible that certain names have been erroneously omitted. Did we miss someone? If so, send us an email at contact@thestridereport.com & let us know!

10. Colorado Buffaloes

We'll admit, there are legitimate arguments to be had that other teams were better suited for our TSR #10 spot than Colorado. In fact, Wake Forest could contest that their latest crop of rookies was outright stronger, especially when you look at their elite duo of Corbin Coombs and Frenchman Aurielian Radja.


However, the counter to that is, a) Colorado's overall talent in their rookie class isn't far off from the Demon Deacons, b) these CU rookies are debatably more proven on the grass, and more importantly, c) this group of freshmen is comparatively more important to the long-term success of the Buffaloes.



Let's start with TJ Hansen, a true high school star who was beyond phenomenal in a variety of events, specifically the mile. There, he clocked a brilliant 3:59 personal best to pair with incredible personal bests of 1:51 (800), 8:10 (3k), 8:51 (two-mile) and 14:24 (5k). Not only that, but Hansen was an elite cross country runner, having placed 2nd (2024) and 10th (2023) at NXN!


On paper, Hansen is everything that Coach Sean Carlson could want and then some. He's an elite three-season threat with outstanding range and proven championship pedigree.


Keegan Smith, meanwhile, isn't too different. Sure, he isn't the same miler that Hansen, but the rest of his resume is fairly similar. With personal bests of 1:51 (800), 4:04 (mile), 8:52 (3200) and 14:23 (5k XC), Smith is another true superstar who can contribute across all three seasons of racing.


Just like Hansen, the cross country credentials of Smith are what truly separate him from everyone else. After all, he placed 6th at NXN and 5th at the Foot Locker XC National Championships, both in 2024.



Together, Smith and Hansen offer a ridiculous amount of firepower on the grass, an area that Colorado is clearly emphasizing with their latest transfer signings of Dominic Serem and Justin Kipkoech over the last year. With a year or two of development, Smith and Hansen could be the backbones of Colorado's cross country squad in their pursuit to land on the podium.


We then come to Jack Graffeo, another key name who, in our eyes, is fairly underrated. Times of 4:09 (mile), 8:52 (two-mile) and 14:41 (5k) in high school make him a perfect fit for the aerobic-centric roster in Boulder, Colorado. And the best part? He's already gotten faster as a collegian, recently running excellent personal bests of 8:13 (3k) and 14:06 (5k) on the indoor oval!


On paper, Graffeo clearly leans towards the longer distances and could be a legitimate 10k standout in the future. That is an area that the Buffalo men had sneaky-good success in last spring as they put five runners under 28:50 for 10,000 meters.


Of course, we still suspect that Graffeo will be a star in cross country after placing 3rd at the 2024 Foot Locker XC National Championships. In fact, when it comes to the grass, this Colorado youngster may be just as good as Smith and Hansen, both now and maybe in the future, too!



The fourth name is where we get a bit of a debate brewing. I am, of course, talking about Trey Caldwell, a former high school star from California. He has run excellent marks of 8:53 (3200) and 14:49 (5k XC). He also secured a 12th place finish at the 2024 Foot Locker XC National Championships.


The challenge, however, is that Caldwell has since transferred out of Boulder, instead opting to join an Arkansas squad that has very much needed a long-term distance piece like himself.


So...does Caldwell count in these rankings?


On one hand, he's not even on this team anymore and he never competed in a Colorado singlet. But on the other hand, he was still part of this rookie class and we did something similar a few years ago on the women's side when Sam McDonnell transferred from Alabama to UCLA halfway through her freshman year.


We'll count Caldwell towards this ranking for Colorado, but we do so with a very, very big asterisk next to his name.



Other athletes such as Wil Ihmels (8:35 for 3k) and Kimi Bulto (1:52 for 800 meters) are solid developmental names to have. The former dominated his competition in the state of North Dakota while the latter brings valuable middle distance speed to a roster that has very little of that.


Coach Sean Carlson took over Colorado with the aim of revamping a long distance group that had truthfully begun to fizzle out. Since then, his recruiting has been outstanding and there is a clear emphasis on cross country. Sure, other groups like Wake Forest may have guys who are outright faster, but these Buffalo freshmen are nearly unmatched in terms of their combined accolades on the grass.



9. Washington Huskies

The Washington men only have two true freshmen on their roster this year.


Yep, you read that right -- just two names.


Naturally, I'm sure many of you are wondering, "How on Earth does one team with only two true freshmen get ranked? Surely these two rookies aren't THAT good...right?"


Well, believe it or not, the first-year duo I am referencing are, in fact, THAT good.


Enter Owen Powell and Josiah Tostenson, a pair of young men who were viewed as the two-most valuable American distance recruits in the Class of 2025. If you think that statement is an exaggeration, then just know that our high school coverage team actually listed Powell and Tostenson as our TSR #1 and TSR #2 recruits in the Class of 2025, respectively, back in June.



Powell, the son of head coaches of Andy Powell and Maurica Powell, is one of the single-most electric and dynamic distance stars in recent memory. His ultra-elite middle distance prowess has led to him running jaw-dropping personal bests of 1:46 (800), 2:23 (1k), 3:36 (1500) and 3:56 (mile). For perspective, that 1500-meter time would have tied Powell with Aidan McCarthy at NCAA #13 on last year's D1 outdoor national leaderboard.


Of course, Powell is plenty accomplished in the longer distances as well. Monster times of 8:04 (3k), 8:38 (3200), 13:30 (three-mile XC) and 14:40 (5k XC) show us that Powell can translate his raw talent to practically any event -- and that's a massive plus for a Washington program that leans on milers to be effective scorers during the fall months.


The elite dynamism of Powell isn't just incredible -- it's overwhelming. He is a perfect fit for a program that is known for developing superstar milers and it doesn't hurt that his coach is also the person who knows him the best (read: his father).


Then there is Josiah Tostenson. While Powell has phenomenal range, it's clear that he has a sweet spot when you get closer to the middle distances. And while Tostenson is fantastic over 1500 meters as well, he is more of a strength-based name by comparison.



With personal bests of 1:48 (800), 3:36 (1500), 3:57 (mile), 7:57 (3k), 8:39 (3200), 13:30 (three-mile XC) and 14:15 (5k), Tostenson isn't too far off from Powell in terms of range. His raw aerobic talent blends beautifully with his proven middle distance speed, making him a massive threat across three seasons. On a mile-centric roster, Tostenson can fit into that role while also stepping up and adding cross country scoring, something that the Husky men very much needed this past fall and in previous seasons.


Put simply, Powell and Tostenson provide everything that Washington could need and want. They are both phenoms, they both hold incredible range, they both fit into the roster ethos of the Husky's program and they are both capable of contributing right away (even if Tostenson's initial start has been slower than expected).


So sure, Washington only has two freshmen, but when they're THIS good, quality matters way, way, way more than quantity.



8. Texas Tech Red Raiders

One of the more interesting teams to monitor over the last few years, specifically when it comes to the new era of NIL and overseas recruiting, has been Texas Tech. The Red Raiders have signed a large handful of impactful international stars in recent years, although many of them have opted to transfer elsewhere.


Put simply, the roster turnover of this middle and long distance program isn't great. That, however, shouldn't take away from how talented the four current rookies on Texas Tech's roster are.


Let's start with Fikadu Gonzalez, a Spanish distance ace who has head-turning credentials. His times of 1:49 (800), 3:38 (1500) and 7:58 (3k) are incredible for a freshman, giving Texas Tech a legitimate three-season threat if that latter PR can be translated to the grass.



The BIG 12 is loaded with middle distance stars over 800 meters and 1500 meters between Iowa State, Oklahoma State and, in some cases, BYU and Colorado. Now, the Red Raiders have an instant-impact name who can contend for conference meet points in an area that they weren't competitive in, previously.


And maybe more importantly, Texas Tech now has the necessary pieces to put Gonzalez on the anchor leg of a nationally competitive DMR! When you realize how many different ways the Spanish distance ace can be utilized, you realize how valuable he is for Texas Tech.


However, some may argue that Gonzalez doesn't even have the best outright personal best of this group. That, instead, may belong to Luke Bone, a Texas native who holds a ridiculously impressive 1:46 PR for 800 meters!


Texas Tech doesn't have the same half-mile history that a program like Iowa State does, but they have had plenty of success with 800-meter runners in the past. That national-caliber success could be reignited with Bone if he is able to replicate his peak level of fitness.



And the best part? There isn't any projection that needs to happen. We know that Bone is a 1:46 runner over 800 meters and that could be enough to put him on the national stage as soon as this spring if all goes well.


Between Gonzalez and Bone, the Texas Tech men are set in the middle distance events with plenty of firepower. That's especially true when you realize that they also have Kyzer Dunbar. He isn't quite as accomplished as Gonzalez or Bone, but a 1:52 (800) PR does give the men of Lubbock even more depth to work with.


Although, we should mention that Dunbar may be a better fit for the 400 meters given that he has run under 47.50 for that distance on both the indoor and outdoor ovals.


But maybe more importantly, the Texas Tech men also addressed the longer distances. After losing a large handful of names to the transfer portal, being able to (slowly) rebuild their cross country squad has been vital. Enter Victor Kipkoech.


The Red Raider rookie was quietly awesome this past fall, emerging as a shockingly impactful name. He took 4th at the Arturo Barrios Invite, was 24th at the BIG 12 XC Championships and stunned many with a fantastic 69th place finish at the NCAA XC Championships!



Texas Tech has made it clear with their recruiting efforts over the last few years that they want to be competitive in cross country. And while the Red Raiders will need to rebuild their longer distance group after multiple departures, Kipkoech gives this team a focal name to build and rally around for the future. A top-70 finish at the cross country national meet is no joke and it offers an aerobic balance to a freshman class that is clearly middle distance-centric.


With a true half-mile star in Bone, an all-around threat in Gonzalez, a possible cross country low-stick in Kipkoech and a key depth piece in Dunbar, you can see why we have Texas Tech ranked at TSR #8 in these freshman class rankings.




bottom of page