TSR's 2024-25 D1 Current Freshman Class Rankings: #1 BYU Cougars (Men)

Written by Mike McKean, edits & additional commentary via Garrett Zatlin
Despite our research, it is possible that certain names have been erroneously omitted. Did we miss someone? If so, send us an email at contact@thestridereport.com & let us know!
NOTE: Athletes who graduated from high school in 2024 and committed to run for BYU are factored into these rankings even if they are currently on missions.
1. BYU Cougars
Following a somewhat convincing win at the 2024 NCAA XC Championships, the BYU men are positioned to continue their reign at the top of the country with another incredible rookie class.
Sure, we’ve become accustomed to BYU reloading year-in and year-out, but this year’s freshman class contains a “wow” factor that we haven’t seen in a few years. That certainly says something when you look at the all-time powerhouse that Coach Ed Eyestone has built in Provo.
To no one's surprise, the Cougars are once again set to continue their dominance on the grass with this crop of aerobically elite rookies. For a program that’s been just as dominant over the 5000-meter and 10,000-meter distances on the oval as they have been on the grass, this freshman class feels destined to continue that trend.
Not only that, but the Cougars have brought in incredibly elite middle distance athletes as well, further bolstering their odds for team success on the oval while offering crucial roster balance.
In fact, BYU has started to develop a trend of consistently landing the nation’s top half-milers. In 2023, the Cougars signed 1:48 (800) man Carter Cutting. And how did they back that up this year? By signing yet another 1:48 (800) runner!
We are, of course, talking about Tyler Mathews.
The dynamic, speed-based, Arizona-bred athlete enters the NCAA with a jaw-dropping personal best that immediately puts him in contention for a national qualifying spot as soon as this year (in a best-case scenario).

In addition to his elite half-mile personal best, Mathews has produced marks of 4:08 (1600) and 1:17 (600). On top of that, the rookie enters the collegiate scene with plenty of championship experience under his belt, having earned a 7th place finish over 800 meters at Nike Outdoor Nationals.
After acclimating to the NCAA, Mathews will almost certainly pose a threat to each 800-meter field that he toes the line against. However, you could argue that his potential in the mile is just as high. In fact, we could see him follow in Carter Cutting’s footsteps and develop more aerobic strength. After seeing Cutting’s recent 3:59 (mile) personal best, it’s plenty realistic to think that the Cougars' coaching staff can get Tyler Mathews to a sub-four mark as well.
While we’re on the topic of elite middle distance runners making their way to Provo, we have to mention one of the most talented athletes in this group.
Enter Zach Hillhouse.
The Utah native is an addition to this freshman class that may actually be a bit under the radar. That, of course, is because Hillhouse is serving a mission in the Philippines for the next two years.
Hillhouse became the 21st high schooler to ever break four minutes in the mile this past summer. Considering a sub-four minute miler to be “under the radar” in the Cougars' rookie class is an embarrassment of riches that virtually no other program can say they have.
That being said, Hillhouse makes it hard to forget his name when you take a gander at his high school accolades. With eye-opening personal bests of 1:50 (800), 3:59 (mile), 9:02 (3200) and 15:10 (5k XC), he has the potential to be a multi-time All-American before his collegiate career is all said and done.
When you factor in his 20th place finish at the 2023 Foot Locker XC National Championships, you get the proof you need that Hillhouse can be an extremely valuable three-season athlete for the Cougars.
On paper, Hillhouse's skillset mimics what we've seen from veteran star Lucas Bons. And over the long-term, the Cougars will seemingly have a true miler (which they haven't always had) who can move up in distance.
Speaking of another athlete who we will have to patiently wait for, we must take the time to acknowledge the most elite high school recruit in the nation: Daniel Simmons.
Despite having already mentioned Tyler Mathews and Zach Hillhouse, the resumes of those two superstars pale in comparison to one of the greatest prep runners ever.
Simmons’ resume speaks for itself. And while he’ll be serving a mission for the next two years, it’s safe to say that he’ll be worth the wait. That's because the all-time ace shattered the high school 5k national record with an other-worldly mark of 13:25 -- that’s a performance that would put Simmons in the qualifying conversation for the NCAA Indoor Championships this year!
The newest Cougar can pair multiple jaw-dropping personal bests to his 5k national record, most notably times of 4:01 (1600) and 8:34 (3200). Simmons also helped his high school team to a winning time of 16:43 (4xMile) at New Balance Indoor Nationals. And if his entire resume wasn’t already impressive enough for you, he also ran 8:36 for 3200 meters…at 4400 feet of elevation.
To land a commitment from one of the all-time greats at the high school level is a massive accomplishment for BYU. Simmons possesses all of the attributes to become one of the most elite distance runners in the NCAA one day. And while that won't be for quite some time, the Cougars could have a long-term replacement for Casey Clinger -- and he may end up being even better.
Austin Westfall and Ben Jaster are two more interesting names. Both are extremely talented rookies who are currently serving missions.
Admittedly, the former’s personal bests on the oval don’t jump off the page. Quite frankly, Westfall’s marks of 2:00 (800) and 4:17 (1600) may fool you into thinking that he’s more of a developmental piece.
However, this rookie’s value is certainly set to come on the grass. With a 4th place finish at the 2023 Nike Cross Nationals to his name, Westfall has what it takes to become a major contributor on the grass for the Cougars before he becomes an upperclassman. Plus, when you factor in his marks of 8:56 (3200) and 14:54 (5k XC), it becomes clear that this rookie will shine in the strength-based events.
As for Ben Jaster, he provides a dynamism that’s matches the nation’s best rookies. Jaster oozes All-American potential, especially considering how aerobically gifted he is. With impressive personal bests of 14:19 (5k track) and 8:38 (3200), don’t be surprised to see him emerge as an integral part of the Cougars' success once he returns from his mission.
If BYU had only landed Jaster, Westfall and a few developmental names, then they still would have had an argument to be listed in our rankings. Instead, they're only the fourth or fifth names who we're mentioning in this freshman class -- and yet, they could each be multi-time All-Americans by the time their college careers end.
Given that both men are aerobic-centric high school stars, their chances of thriving at BYU seem plenty high given the Cougars' history of success in the longer events.
One runner who has already made their BYU debut is none other than Berkley Nance. He was spectacular on the grass in his freshman campaign, making an impact on day one.
While Nance only competed in two contests for the Cougars this past fall, he made his presence known. With an impressive win in the “B” race at the Nuttycombe Invite, the rookie was immediately thrown onto our radar. After a 15th place finish at the Bill Dellinger Invitational, it became clear that Nance was poised to eventually develop into a future low-stick for the Cougars.
Of course, this was hardly shocking when you take into account his success at the high school level. With personal bests of 9:03 (two-mile) and 14:43 (5k XC), Nance becomes one of the more underrated distance signings from the Class of 2024. That's especially true when you consider that he earned a massive 4th place finish at the 2023 Foot Locker XC National Championships.
And when you realize that, it makes plenty of sense why this fast-rising freshman star seemingly looked so comfortable on the grass this past fall.

The final name of BYU’s wildly-impressive rookie class is Landon Heemeyer, another Rocky Mountain (ID) product who holds fantastic personal bests of 4:09 (mile), 9:01 (two-mile) and 14:38 (5k XC). When factoring in his 9th place result at the 2022 Foot Locker XC National Championships and 14th place finish at the 2023 Nike Cross Nationals, it’s easy to see why we’re such strong believers in the Idaho native.
Heemeyer's performances at big-time championship races make him an explosive name with a high ceiling. In fact, we think that he has the potential to be just as good as Nance could be one day. Once Heemeyer does make his collegiate debut, it wouldn't surprise us if he was an instant contributor.
To put it simply, BYU's freshman class is more than just elite. In an era where college coaches are flocking to the international ranks to find new recruits, Coach Ed Eyestone has continued to lean on domestic talents to further bolster an already-incredible distance roster.
And based on this year's group, he couldn't have done much better.
This year's collection of BYU rookies are predominantly strength-based, making them perfect fits for the identity of this roster. The Cougars landed the single-best recruit in the country via Danny Simmons, but they also established greater event diversity by adding elite speed-based talents such as Zach Hillhouse and Tyler Mathews.
With that kind of raw talent, it's hard to say that any other freshman class in the country was as good as what BYU recruited.
.png)


