top of page

2026 John McNichols Invite First Thoughts: BYU Men & NAU Women Thrive, Kelvin Cheruiyot & Brighter Jepchumba Emerge Victorious in Tight Battles

Writer: Admin (Garrett Zatlin)
Admin (Garrett Zatlin)
Sep 19
10 min read

Cross country is SO back! The John McNichols Invite is all wrapped up and there is A TON to talk about. As such, we offered analysis on every team that finished in the top-15 of the standings in Terre Hate on Saturday morning. We also briefly touched on the individual battles as well.


And yes, for the sake of time, we are implementing our "three sentences or less" rule, meaning that we can only offer no more than three sentences worth of analysis per team.


Let's dive in, shall we?

Men's Analysis

1. BYU Cougars (71 points)

The BYU men were just flat-out better than their competition on Saturday morning. Tayvon Kitchen (3rd) was brilliant and the supporting cast was absolutely flawless as Noah Jenkins, James Corrigan, Dalton Mortensen and Isaac Hedengren went 14-16-18-20, respectively. Their depth after those men was far from great, but Dalton Mortensen deserves kudos for a better-than-expected performance.


BYU men competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
BYU men competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

2. Florida Gators (119 points)

I cannot begin to express how insanely impressive this performance was from Florida. Sure, Kelvin Cheruiyot was outstanding en route to winning gold, but this group succeeded because Geofrey Ronoh (9th) was brilliant, Josh Ruiz (17th) made a HUGE jump in his fitness and Ian Sanchez Lopez (37th) was plenty serviceable. The catch, however, is that the Gators didn't even have star ace Eliud Muchiri, either, meaning that they still have greater scoring potential within them.


3. Washington Huskies (190 points)

This was a very important result for the Washington men who will leave Terre Haute with more-than-enough Kolas points to safely qualify for the NCAA XC Championships...right? Tyrone Gorze (13th) is healthy and better than ever while the supporting cast of Josiah Tostenson (41st), Nathan Neil (43rd), Jamar Distel (44th) and Isaac Briggs (49th) was plenty stable. Sure, the Huskies seemingly have limited firepower, but they looked very strong and steady through five runners.


4. Stanford Cardinal (205 points)

This was a huge result for a Stanford team that needed a confidence-boosting performance after a nightmare 2025 fall campaign. No, they weren't particularly exciting in terms of firepower, but Paul Bergeron (24th) looked plenty strong and Lex Young (35th), while not at his best, looked very solid. Given that Leo Young had a clear "off" day, there is still so much more upside within this team that they can tap into moving forward.


5. Washington State Cougars (212 points)

All things considered, this was a fantastic result for the Washington State men. Sure, the duo of Solomon Kipchoge (4th) and Evans Kurui (5th) was elite as expected, but it was Kutoven Stevens posting an awesome 28th place finish that took us by surprise. We should also mention that the Cougars didn't have either of their two Kenyan newcomers for this race, meaning that WSU could be FAR better in the future as long as those men actually race this fall.


Solomon Kipchoge charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
Solomon Kipchoge charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

6. Michigan State Spartans (212 points)

If I am the Michigan State men, then I am fairly happy with this result. Thomas Westphal (8th) looks like a true star, while Lezawe Osterink (31st) and Michael Hegarty (52nd) were awesome middle-lineup scorers who offered great stability. Yes, it's true, Riley Hough (61st) struggled, but as long as Saturday was just a fluke for him, then the Spartans will be noticeably better moving forward.


7. Northern Arizona Lumberjacks (232 points)

I'll admit, I was a bit underwhelmed by the Northern Arizona men on Saturday morning. Make no mistake, the trio of Erik Le Roux (15th), Ethan Godsey (32nd) and Manny Perez (36th) were very strong, but their final two scorers settled for 72nd place and 77th place. That said, we didn't see Iker Sanchez Lopez, Justin Keyes, Reinhardt Harrison or Ford Washburn, meaning that the Lumberjacks will likely be better in the future.


8. Utah Valley Wolverines (265 points)

Wow, what an absolutely HUGE performance for the Utah Valley men as they smashed expectations with an 8th place finish. Silas Kiplagat (19th) was as good as he reasonably could be, but it was his supporting cast (featuring Alex Hartshorn, Trey Despain, Mark Boyle and Wyatt Mortenson) that was shockingly complete and void of any gaps. And remember, the Wolverines still have a star-caliber name in Thomas Boyden on their roster who didn't even race on Saturday.


9. Wisconsin Badgers (267 points)

Sure, the Wisconsin men didn't have top ace Matan Ivri, but it's hard to be all that excited about the results that we saw from the Badgers on Saturday. Johnny Livingstone (11th) was outstanding, fully delivering on the potential that we knew he had, but no other Wisconsin runner cracked the top-40 and Liam Newhart (78th) wasn't nearly as potent as we thought he could be. It's best not to overreact to this performance, but this wasn't exactly the most exciting start to the season for Wisconsin.


Johnny Livingstone charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
Johnny Livingstone charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

10. Butler Bulldogs (275 points)

This is roughly what we thought the Butler men were capable of, although it was also on the better side of our expectations for them. Will Zegarski (12th) was as good as we could have reasonably expected him to be, and Graham Tomori (39th) looks like a promising name. Even so, there was a clear gap after those two men as no other Bulldog cracked the top-60.


11. Harvard Crimson (277 points)

This may look like a concerning result on the surface, but in reality, this was actually an extremely encouraging performance. Tam Gavenas (7th) looks like a true star while Ben Bouie (29th) had a monster race to emerge as a high-impact middle-lineup scorer! Given that fellow low-sticks Charlie Ortmans and Sam Burgess didn't even race on Saturday, the Harvard men should be extremely happy with how they fared.


12. Eastern Kentucky Colonels (312 points)

On one hand, the Eastern Kentucky men didn't have All-American Brian Kimutai or Kenyan newcomer Abel Kirui for this race. However, on the other hand, everyone else in their projected lineup was racing, and they largely underwhelmed. Sure, Taha Er Raouy (21st) looked strong, and Enoch Bokaba (47th) looked solid, but names like Brett Rushman, Bradley Giblin, Aiden Coles and Mohammed Jouhari were far from exciting as they all failed to crack the top-70.


13. Utah State Aggies (328 points)

I feel like the Utah State men should be fairly happy with this performance. Garrett Woodhouse (33rd), Jed Megargel (47th) and Walker Cole (56th) formed a quietly strong scoring trio which made up for a few backend gaps. No, they weren't perfect, but a 13th place finish in this field is going to at least put the Aggies in the national qualifying conversation...I think.


Garrett Woodhouse charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
Garrett Woodhouse charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

14. California Baptist Lancers (338 points)

I'll be honest, I thought this team was going to be SO much better on Saturday than they actually were. Sure, Pedro Marin (37th) looked phenomenal, and Yemane Mulugeta (27th) was highly effective as well. However, with no other CBU runner cracking the top-80, and their fifth scorer fading back to an ugly 144th place finish, there was only so much that the Lancers could do in this field.


15. Georgia Bulldogs (353 points)

This may look like a poor result, but in the grand scheme of things, it's actually pretty strong. The Georgia men didn't have star ace Valentin Soca, and their fifth runner took 141st place in this field. If you add Soca into the results, then the Bulldogs are likely closer to the top-seven in the team standings.


Individual Race

I fully acknowledge that Florida's Kelvin Cheruiyot is an exceptionally elite talent with a huge aerobic engine. Even so, seeing him take down a name like Elsingi Kipruto for the individual title is a legitimate upset. And frankly, his ability to make up so much ground in the final stretch was so absurd that it took me (and likely Kipruto) by surprise.



Women's Analysis


1. Northern Arizona Lumberjacks (61 points)

I said in our meet preview that the Northern Arizona women had a real shot at winning the team title despite missing a few key names. Even so, I didn't think that they would be THIS good. Sure, Ava Mitchell (7th), Grace Copeland (14th) and Addy Ritzenhein (20th) perfectly matched expectations, but Elsa Sundqvist (9th) and Eleanor Voykin (12th) came out of nowhere while Emma Stutzman (19th) was better than expected.


Northern Arizona women competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
Northern Arizona women competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

2. Utah Utes (107 points)

Many of us at The Stride Report were very high on the Utah women coming into this season, and they showed the NCAA why on Saturday morning. Erin Vringer (10th) was a true star and Annastasia Peters (21st) met expectations, but it was the supporting cast of Tayla Gunton (23rd), Josie Fale (26th) and Millie Wilcox (27th) that was so much better than we thought they would be. They may not have come close to winning gold, but this was a incredibly encouraging performance that has validated their preseason hype.


3. Washington State Cougars (121 points)

This was a weird result for the Washington State women. Millie Bii (6th) was phenomenal, emerging as a true low-stick ace, while Nelly Jimeli (18th) was exactly as good as we thought she should be. Caroline Jepkorir (25th), Lauren Hoyt (35th) and Mercy Biwott (37th) were all very solid in their own right, but standout ace Zenah Cheptoo (55th) clearly had an "off" day, thus limiting the Cougars' ability to contend with Utah.


4. Toledo Rockets (124 points)

The firepower within this Toledo lineup is better than some people realize, as Purity Chepkirui (8th) was as good as advertised while Melody Jebiwot (15th) and Dorcas Kiptanui (16th) looked outstanding as secondary scorers. Although Karina James (42nd), Lianna Surtz (43rd) and Bella Earl (51st) were a bit further back, the depth that they offered was very stable and went beyond their fifth runner.


5. Florida Gators (156 points)

This was a fine performance for the Florida women who were headlined by Judy Chepkoech (3rd) and Desma Chepkoech (5th) as expected. I also thought Isobelle Jones (31st) and freshman Maggie McCormick (45th) had fairly solid outings given their youth. However, the Gators were without a key name in Reagan Gilmore who could have more effectively bridged the gap between Florida's scorers.


Desma Chepkoech (left) & Judy Chepkoech (right) competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
Desma Chepkoech (left) & Judy Chepkoech (right) competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

6. Washington Huskies (176 points)

Coach Maurica Powell should be plenty happy with this result. The Husky women didn't field Julia David-Smith, and Mia Cochran isn't eligible to race (yet), but the Seattle-based ladies had five scorers -- Abby Hennessy, Nicole Bissell, Elena Aldrink, Josephine Welin and Sherry Drury -- settle between 29th place and 39th place. That is extremely reassuring as they can get noticeably better with the reintroduction of a low-stick or two later this fall.


7. Boston College Eagles (217 points)

I admittedly thought that the Boston College women would be slightly better on Saturday morning than they ultimately were. Even so, it's hard to be upset at their lineup structure as Imogen Gardiner (17th), Ella Fadil (32nd) and Annabelle Miller (40th) were plenty effective. That said, Claire Daniels (65th) and Natalie Millerova (70th) can likely be better, and we didn't see Rosalie Ten Bruggencate, either.


8. Eastern Kentucky Colonels (248 points)

It goes without saying that Brighter Jepchumba (1st) was unbelievably impressive, emerging as a borderline superstar on Saturday, while Edna Chelulei (4th) was as good as we expected her to be. The heroes of this team, however, may actually be Morgan Kobylinski (34th) and Metrine Jelimo (84th), who both beat expectations. Yes, fifth scorer Ann Kiplagat did fade to 138th place, but for a team that only fielded five runners, this was a very strong result for the Eastern Kentucky women.


9. Michigan State Spartans (267 points)

Considering the unexciting seasons that they have had in recent years, I thought the Michigan State women had a fairly respectable outing on Saturday morning. Taylor Pangburn (28th) was a very strong lead scorer while the rest of the Spartans' scorers went 52-56-66-71. This isn't the flashiest lineup ever, but the depth and compact nature of this team should give the Michigan State women a fairly high floor at larger invitationals.


Taylor Pangburn competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
Taylor Pangburn competing at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

10. Louisville Cardinals (280 points)

When it comes to the Louisville women, their lineup structure was roughly aligned with what we were expecting to see. Nancy Chepleting (13th) was a true low-stick, Winne Chebet (22nd) turned out to be a high-impact newcomer and Haley Meade (60th) continues to make subtly great progress. Yes, there were gaps throughout this lineup, but salvaging a 10th place finish in this field was encouraging to see.


11. Utah Valley Wolverines (284 points)

We weren't aware that Kenyan rookie Caren Kipsirat (11th) had been signed by Utah Valley, but her introduction to this program gave the Wolverines a new low-stick to rally around. However, it was Reagan Doman (24th) who was far more effective than we thought she would be. Underclassmen Rozlyn Stowe (61st) and Sophia Biesinger (72nd) were both plenty stable as support scorers, although UVU will need to address their fifth scoring spot (128th) moving forward.


12. Indiana Hoosiers (311 points)

We can't say enough good things about Katy Zang (2nd) who looked absolutely incredible as she battled at the front of this field. However, Lily Myers (48th) and Maddie Rocchio (49th) deserve a lot of credit for how they performed, offering tons of middle-lineup scoring value. Yes, their backend scorers will need to be better moving forward, but I was extremely impressed with the Hoosiers as a whole on Saturday.


13. Georgia Bulldogs (335 points)

Truthfully, I was not very high on the Georgia women coming into this season. And while I still don't see them as a national qualifying squad, I do have to admit that they were better than I thought they would be in Terre Haute. With finishes of 47-54-64-88-96, the Bulldogs showed that they hold great promise and could be a legitimate national-caliber threat in the future.


Anastasia Nilsson charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg
Anastasia Nilsson charging to the finish line at the John McNichols Invite // Photo via Griffin Forberg

14. Air Force Falcons (358 points)

I truthfully don't have much to say about this performance as the Air Force women were roughly as good as we thought they would be. Anna Harden (50th) and Ella Johnson (58th) had solid outings, and all five of the Falcons' scorers cracked the top-100. Even so, there wasn't anything particularly great or bad about this final result.


15. Harvard Crimson (406 points)

Everything that I said about the Air Force women largely applies to the Harvard women. Aelo Curtis (68th) was quietly solid and Sophia Gorriaran (75th) deserves a nod of respect for her efforts. Keep in mind that Dylan McElhinney didn't compete, so the Crimson could theoretically be a bit more dangerous later this season as long as she actually toes the line.


Individual Race

I was absolutely stunned to see Brighter Jepchumba and Katy Zang perform as well as they did on Saturday. We knew the former name was talented, but I never once thought that she could win this race. Zang, meanwhile, was fearless despite her rookie status, and I thought she showed tremendous resilience in an individual battle that tested her nearly every step of the way.




bottom of page