2025 NCAA Championships First Thoughts (Part One): Ishmael Kipkurui Claims NCAA 10k Title, Jack Crull Unleashes Incredible Kick & Top Distance Stars Shockingly Miss Finals

To say that the first day of action at the NCAA Outdoor Championships was eventful would be an understatement -- a very big understatement. Between a 10k thriller, stunning finals omissions in the men's 1500 meters and a glaring DNS from Tinoda Matsatsa over 800 meters, Wednesday's results left us with TONS to talk about.
Without further ado, let's chat about a carnage-filled first day of racing...
Liam Murphy, Abel Teffra & Colin Sahlman Shockingly Miss 1500-Meter Finals, Bradley's Jack Crull Overcomes Underdog Status
Oh boy, where do we even start?
The first heat of the men's 1500-meter prelims is where nearly all of the madness from Wednesday happened. An ultra-pedestrian pace through the first 800 meters led to a wild barrage of kicks, especially over the last lap. And with so many massive surges being throw in during the latter-half of that race, positioning was arguably just as important as turnover was.
When the dust settled, both Liam Murphy (Villanova) and Abel Teffra (Georgetown) found themselves outside of the top-five automatic qualifiers to the finals in their heat. Murphy needed to wait on the results of heat two to see if he would get a time-based qualifier, something that didn't happen. Teffra, meanwhile, faded...hard.

Typically, results as glaring as those can often be explained by poor tactics or miscalculated moves. That, however, simply wasn't the case for either of these men. Despite both distance stars building their reputations around historically-great kicks, both men ran out of steam in the final 200 meters, unable to maintain their turnover for as long as their competitors.
Murphy has truthfully struggled at the NCAA Outdoor Championships...a lot. He finished second-to-last in the 1500-meter finals in both 2023 and 2024 and didn't even reach the finals this time around. That's ultimately why I had the Villanova star and collegiate record holder placing 8th in my predictions -- tactically, this stage has been incredibly challenging for him.
As for Teffra, seeing him fade as much as he did was stunning. Yes, he is best known for his mile national title win this past winter, but the entirety of his spring campaign suggested that he was still in contention for NCAA gold! Wednesday was likely just a fluke more than anything else, but not having him or Liam Murphy in the finals should give guys like Nathan Green, Ethan Strand, Gary Martin and even Adam Spencer a sense of relief.

We then come to Colin Sahlman, a guy who simply hasn't been at his best this spring. The NAU star raced sparingly this season and when he did, he simply lacked the explosiveness that we've grown so used to seeing from him.
On Wednesday, the Northern Arizona star found himself in the back of the pack of heat one. And unfortunately for him, he waited too long to get in position as the top of the field broke away before he could move up enough.
Even so, Sahlman will be back on this stage and there is zero question that he will be better in the future. This is far from his best form and his 2024 spring campaign already validates that statement.
Also, how about Bradley's Jack Crull? The Braves' veteran was outstanding en route to his heat one win, putting together a brilliant tactical race and showcasing a tremendous amount of late-race speed.
Can anyone guess how fast his last lap was?
Don't worry, I'll give you time to ponder and make a guess.
Alright, have a split in your head?
Ready?
The answer is 50.62 seconds.
That was the final 400-meter split that Crull threw down, just barely faster than Trent McFarland (Michigan), Brendan Herger (Michigan), Gary Martin (Virginia) and Colin Sahlman (Northern Arizona), each of whom split under 51 seconds on that final lap.
I was talking to multi-time All-American, Isaac Basten, earlier today. The former Drake star competed against Crull fairly often in the Missouri Valley Conference. His text to me? "Finally people understand why it was never easy for me to beat Jack Crull at conference."
You are very right Isaac, people ARE beginning to understand.

Also, what a day for Michigan! Coach Kevin Sullivan just put both of his men in the 1500-meter finals in a historically stacked year for the event! In terms of speed development and tactical execution, both Herger and McFarland have been beyond brilliant this spring.
I would like to chat more about the second heat of the men's 1500-meter prelims, but there isn't a whole lot to chat about. That race was very straightforward and the top contenders delivered on expectations.
Men's 3k Steeplechase Goes Chalk...Very, Very, Chalk
On a day that was filled with stunning results and tons of entertainment, it was only right that one of the men's races was comparatively quieter. That race was, of course, the 3000-meter steeplechase.
For the most part, nearly everyone who was favored to advance to the 3000-meter steeplechase finals did exactly that. There were, however, two possible exceptions.
Akron's Bismack Kipchirchir, a guy who has run 8:27 over the barriers and water pits this season, did not advance to the finals. For the most part, he was excellent on the outdoor oval and his last-place seeding in this event was only because he took a late-race fall at the East Regional Championships.
NC State's Brett Gardner also failed to make it out of the prelims. That was a minor surprise considering that the Wolfpack veteran ran 8:29 in the steeple earlier this year and was the ACC champion in this event.

And yet, when you sit back and really think about it, neither of those omissions are totally shocking. Only two our six TSR writers predicted Gardner to be an All-American and only one writer predicted Kipchirchir to earn that same honor...and that writer was me.
Did I think that both of these men were going to make the finals? Yes, I did, but seeing them not make it out of the prelims isn't exactly stunning, either.
As for the top of this field, Iowa State's Joash Ruto looks like he is peaking at just the right time after running 8:22 in the prelims. I'm a big fan of this Cyclone star who has been incredibly poised and productive during his first year in the NCAA. His prior lack of collegiate experience has clearly not held him back.

And maybe more importantly, Ruto's consistency at the highest levels of his fitness -- now running under 8:30 in the steeple four times this spring -- theoretically gives him a high floor going into Friday.
The only question, however, is whether or not Ruto exerted too much energy on Wednesday to be just as effective in his race tomorrow evening.
Abdullahi Hassan Misses 800-Meter Finals While Tinoda Matsatsa Does Not Toe the Line Due to Quad Strain
The men's 800 meters was bound to have some notable omissions from the finals. After all, there are only nine spots available for Friday's race and, in my estimate, there were up to six (or even seven) men who could have realistically won the national title in this event.
Unfortunately, one star-caliber name -- and maybe the consensus favorite for NCAA gold over 800 meters this spring -- didn't even get the chance to toe the line for the prelims on Wednesday. I am, of course, talking about Georgetown's Tinoda Matsatsa. The Stride Report was able to confirm that the Hoya ace sustained a quad strain last Friday. And while it is "runnable," he simply wasn't able to race on it.
And then there is Mississippi State's Abdullahi Hassan, someone who shockingly didn't make it out of the second prelim heat. That was a total stunner considering that the Bulldog star was, a) considered a national title favorite, and b) finished runner-up in this event at the NCAA Indoor Championships.
Despite how he raced at the indoor national meet, Hassan has always struck me a guy who is at his best in honestly-paced races. That's why I was surprised to see the Mississippi State talent choose to play his prelim more tactical, kicking hard with 200 meters to go, but having to settle for 4th place in his heat.
But what was arguably even more surprising was seeing Hassan's teammate, Samuel Navarro, make it to the 800-meter finals instead! The Bulldog runner dropped a 1:45.32 PR in his prelim heat to place 3rd overall and get into the finals on time. That was a stunning result considering that Navarro dropped just over a full second from his personal best.

In fact, there were numerous PRs in that first section of the men's 800-meter prelims. Tyrice Taylor (Arkansas), Koitatoi Kidali (Oregon), Navarro and Matthew Erickson (Oregon) ALL ran 1:45 for 800 meters with three of those men earning new personal bests (Kidali ran 1:42 last summer). Samuel Rodman (Princeton) also advanced to the 800-meter finals with a 1:46-low PR of his own, an exciting way for him to cap his Ivy League career.
Funny enough, Erickson's aggressive front-running approach in the first-half of his race was simultaneously risky and safe. He faded hard at the end and would have been in danger of not making the 800-meter finals if another heat had run faster. But because he opted to make his preliminary heat honest, the Canadian middle distance star safely secured a time-based bid and will be able to defend his indoor national title on Friday.
With both Matsatsa and Hassan out of the 800-meter finals, along with Penn State's Handal Roban, there remains four men who could realistically win the national title tomorrow evening (depending on which of our writers you ask). That would be Christian Jackson (Virginia Tech), Matthew Erickson (Oregon), Sam Whitmarsh (Texas A&M) and Aidan McCarthy (Cal Poly).
New Mexico Duo of Ishmael Kipkurui & Habtom Samuel Go 1-2 Over 10,000 Meters in Tactical Affair
I was convinced that this would be an honest, fast-paced race. If the winning time wasn't under 28:00, then I figured that it would almost certainly be under 28:30. That, however, was not the case.
In a 10k field that was filled aerobic-based stars and aggressive pace pushers, I was not just surprised, I was STUNNED that none of those men opted to make this race significantly faster. That is extremely rare given the skillsets and racing tendencies of the guys who were in this field.

Sure, Furman's Dylan Schubert, BYU's Joey Nokes and Tulane's Bernard Cheruiyot exchanged the lead a few times in the first-half of this race. However, it wasn't until the few laps when things began to ramp up for what was ultimately a kicker's race on the final lap. And truthfully, I thought that was the LAST thing that Habtom Samuel wanted.
However, what I didn't necessarily consider is that a tactical race didn't play into the favor of pretty much anyone other than Kipkurui! He did, after all, prove earlier this year that his kick is among the absolute best in the NCAA, at least over 10,000 meters. Sure enough, with 200 meters to go, the race was essentially over as Kipkurui opened up his stride and powered home to gold. Samuel put together a strong kick of his own to snag silver.
And yet, despite the race unfolding in a way that I did not at all expect, the results ended up being mostly on par with our expectations!
Yes, I'll admit, Denis Kipngetich (Oklahoma State), Drew Bosley (Northern Arizona) and Victor Kiprop (Alabama) not finishing as All-Americans was a bit surprising. But at the same time, those guys are aggressive front-runners who don't typically fare well in sit-and-kick races anyway.
Not only that, but of the men who did finish as All-Americans, the only surprise (if you can even call it that) was Iowa State's Rodgers Kiplimo taking 4th place overall! He had a tremendous day and finally put together a complete season that was great from start to finish. Major kudos to him as seasonal consistency had previously been a challenge for the Cyclone talent.
Regardless, the biggest winners of the day have to be New Mexico, but for beyond the obvious reasons. Two long distance superstars proved that they don't need to run from the front and be aggressive with their pace pushing in order to be successful on the national stage. Tactical affairs and all-out efforts can both produce fruitful results for them, at least over the 10,000-meter distance.
.png)